Just before 1:00am this morning, the jury in the case of Vernon Hershberger handed down 3 “Not Guilty” decisions all related to supposed licensing violations. The licensing issues cited were:
- operating a retail food establishment without a license
- operating a dairy plant without a license
- operating a dairy farm without a milk producers license
Vernon Hershberger was found not guilty of these charges, because he was not participating in these actions. He was coordinating a food buying club where members of the club had ownership interest in the food items obtained. This may seem like splitting hairs to some, but allow me to explain why that is not the case.
Food buying clubs and herdshare programs for raw dairy are arising in all parts of our country because they meet a need. The groups evolve not from mass marketing or a desire to grow powerful corporations. These groups evolve because of two basic facts:
- Small family farmers that have been the very fabric of our society for centuries are focused on high quality, nutrient dense foods and see the adulteration of that food as a violation of what their profession is really about, and
- The American people are becoming informed and are desiring to cast a “No Confidence” vote in the nutritional value and safety of the food that stocks most of our grocery store shelves.
The greatest opposition to these groups are governmental agencies and large agribusiness. In the case of raw dairy, I am quite honestly not sure why the large dairy refineries/agribusinesses are causing such a fuss. It is their direct opposition and the press that arises from their fight that brings more and more attention to the actual quality and value of commercial grade products in the grocery.
The reality is that there are really not enough people like ourselves or the Hershbergers that are crazy enough to undertake this lifestyle to make a dent in the market share of the major commercial dairy players.
Dairy farming is a very arduous way of life that requires a degree of commitment and physical labor that most people would never be willing to exchange their current lifestyle for. It requires being present for milking in all types of weather every 12 hours every day. This means no family vacations to Disney World. No days off even on Christmas morning to open gifts with the family. It means visiting family out of state with only part of your family while the rest stay at home to tend to the herd. This is the life of the normal commercial dairy man.
Now add onto to this the extra commitment of the Raw Milk Dairy Farmer. These farmers must not only milk every 12 hours, but go out over expanses of pasture to round of the cows for milking, because the cows truly graze on fresh grass rather than be contained in a feedlot right off the milking parlor. These farmers spend immensely more time, money, and care in the cleaning of the cows, facilities, and equipment to insure a quality product rather than relying on chemical agents and adulterating processes that help to nullify the harmful effects of the contaminants in the milk.
On the administrative side, these families open up their homes at various hours for owners to visit, pick up their milk, and tour their facilities. They must be available for the pick up or delivery of the milk rather than having the commercial milk truck come to get all the milk. Time is spent by these families in assisting the ownership in getting their milk in containers for transport to their homes. By the very nature of having many families acquiring the milk from their cows rather than it being purchased by the commercial dairy processors, it also means countless hours each month in maintaining indepth financial and legal records to keep the farm solvent and on strong legal ground.
For these reasons, supply will probably never reach demand in this market from a pure economics standpoint.
Why all this discussion when we are talking about licensing issues for a buying club? Simply stated, seeking out nutrient dense food is more work for everyone. It is much easier for the farmer and the consumer to go to Walmart to obtain a gallon of milk. By our very nature, human beings desire leisure and recreation. We all live for the proverbial “Friday at 5:00″ so we can hit the carefree life of the weekend. Those individuals that go to the length of joining food buying clubs and making the financial and time commitment to participate have done their own research and come to the decision that what they are gaining is worth the effort expended. Unfortunately, the opposition to these buying clubs and herdshare programs by the government really hold the basis of their argument in the underlying premise that American adults are not educated enough to research the quality of the food they are getting and are either too ignorant or too careless to protect the health of their families from the food that is obtained. That train of thought begs for the question to be asked, “If American adults are to ignorant to make these decisions, what grade does that give to our governmentally run and funded educational system?” But that is a different soapbox for a different day….
The verdict found by this jury of Mr. Hershberger’s peers is not just stating that he didn’t violate the state statutes, but goes further in its implications that American adults can:
- still enter into private contracts with farmers to obtain the food that they feel is best for their families (even if our forefathers would have thought it ludicrous for individuals to have to have a contract to obtain food from a farmer);
- make intelligent choices about what food is best for their families;
- be dedicated to serving their fellow man will wholesome food directly from the farm without it having to be processed and adulterated by outside agencies that are not accountable to either the farmer or the individual consuming the food.
May we rejoice, but not rest on our laurels. The fight is far from over. A fight for rights that should be considered inalienable to every human being in our nation, but now must be regained through legal battles and the outcry of the people!
{ 2 comments }



